mathdittos2.com

...dedicated to...hmmm, we're still figuring that one out...

Google

Web

mathdittos2.com

About EdNews
News
Archive
mathdittos2.com
Features

 

Monday, November 29, 2010

Bashing Teachers

Stephanie Salter takes on the Indiana education "reform" crowd in Bashing teachers in the name of education reform. She does a good job of exposing the agenda of Governor Mitch Daniels and State Super Tony Bennett to "remake it [education in Indiana] as closely as possible in the image of a highly-competitive, ultra-efficient business." She goes on to show how unrealistic such proposals are and how the pair's school bashing is so unfair to Indiana's students, parents, and teachers. While written for a local audience, Steph's piece could easily be applied to the national education debate.

Odds 'n' Ends

For Moodle users, the open source course management system was upgraded to version 2.0 last week. Generally, classroom teachers don't have to worry about Moodle upgrades, as school system administrators take care of those chores. But if you can't wait to take a peek at the new version the XAMPP package installs in just a few steps.

It now appears that approval of Cathie Black as chancellor for New York City schools is a done deal. Mayor and State Reach Deal on a Schools Chief tells the story of how someone who has no education degree and has never taught a day can become the leader of one of the nation's largest school systems. Larry Cuban analyzes how such a thing could come to be in Why non-educator school chiefs aren't the answer.

Send Feedback to

 

 

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Graduation Rate Up

Results vary a good bit geographically, but overall, U.S. high school graduation rates have begun to rise. A study released yesterday by America's Promise Alliance, Civic Enterprises, and the Everyone Graduates Center at Johns Hopkins University, Building a Grad Nation: Progress and Challenge in Ending the High School Dropout Epidemic (3.9 MB PDF document), found the national graduation rate has gone up from 72 percent in 2001 to 75 percent in 2008.

Gates and Ravitch

Newsweek's Jonathan Alter served up a "home team" article this week about Bill Gates ranting against seniority in education in a speech to the Council of Chief State School Officers. In A Case of Senioritis: Gates tackles education's two-headed monster, Alter inadvertently reveals his bias by calling Diane Ravitch "a jaundiced former Education Department official," before quoting Gates as saying:

Does she like the status quo? Is she sticking up for decline? Does she really like 400-page [union] contracts? Does she think all those 'dropout factories' are lonely? If there's some other magic way to reduce the dropout rate, we're all ears.

Ravitch got a chance to respond on The Answer Sheet blog in Ravitch answers Gates. She also has an excellent, related article this week on her Bridging Differences blog, Bill Gates Listens to the Wrong People.

LAUSD Lays Off 1,000

More than 1,000 L.A. Unified workers lose their jobs by Rick Rojas relates that over a thousand mostly uncertified support employees of the Los Angeles Unified School District have been laid off effective this week. While no teachers were included in this round of layoffs, those cut included office staff, library aides, and custodians. Rojas writes, "Thousands of others will be shifted to new workplaces, with some taking positions with less pay and fewer hours."

Odds 'n' Ends

Walt Gardner's The Downside of Mayoral Control of Schools is a good read. Education reform: Have business-savvy officials improved big-city schools is a good recap of the mayoral control issue, but doesn't really answer the question in its headline.

And Bill Turque reports that Nathan Saunders won a run-off election to become the next president of the Washington Teachers' Union in Washington Teachers' Union president George Parker loses run-off election.

I linked on Monday to Stephanie Salter's excellent opinion piece from the Terre Haute Tribune-Star, Bashing teachers in the name of education reform. While Steph talks about a local school system, its teachers and students, and Indiana officials, her thrust could easily be applied to our national discussion about education "reform."

Besides sending Stephanie a quick "thank you" and compliment, I also shared the url for the story with a national education writer for possible reposting. That didn't happen, so I'm going to re-post it here.

Bashing Teachers in the Name of Education Reform
by Stephanie Salter
(originally published in the Terre Haute Tribune-Star, November 28, 2010)

As I read the Tribune-Star's recent Page 1 news packages about the governor's push for education reform, I kept seeing faces.

Faces of all the women and men I know who make their living as public school teachers. Faces of so many of the kids these teachers work with, nurture, rescue, educate, empower and, more than you'd imagine, come to love.

A quote by Tony Bennett, Indiana State Superintendent of Public Education, has stuck with me with particular power: "I'm tired of hearing all the reasons why something may not work. What we're doing now isn't working. It's time to try something different."

I looked at the list of 29 Vigo County public schools. I imagined the nearly 16,000 children and teenagers inside them and the 1,650 or so teachers, administrators and support staff spending seven to 10 hours each day working to make those kids better readers and writers, helping them learn to solve math problems and grasp scientific principles, and enabling them to try to grow up and be productive citizens.

I pictured walking into each of those buildings, opening the door to every classroom, interrupting the teacher's presentation, the test or student report, looking each and every adult and kid in the eye and saying, "What you are doing isn't working."

That science fair for which you are preparing? The math contest? The debate tournament? The creative writing project? The history, social studies, political science, economics or typing quiz you're taking? Forget them.

The chief of Indiana's public education system (and, by proxy, the governor) says what you do, day in and day out, for more than nine months a year, is broken. It doesn't work and needs to be overhauled to the point of near-abandonment.

The chief calls what you teachers have dedicated your lives to, what you students do in response to your teachers' efforts, "a mess." He compares your system of operation to the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. He has a PowerPoint show — stocked with everything he finds wrong, but devoid of anything you do right — to prove what a mess you've made.

And he and the governor have numbers. Short on context or edifying comparison, long on political spin, the selective statistics damn Hoosier public schools and the people who teach and learn in them.

As sharp a salesman as ever came along, the governor knows the buzzwords and hot-button phrases that cause lots of folks to see red and to believe a fix is fairly easy. In the passionate and impatient Bennett, who seems never to have met a bona fide public school he liked (as opposed to a "public charter school"), Gov. Daniels has found the perfect instrument for advancing his vision of many aspects of government, including public education:

Remake it as closely as possible in the image of a highly-competitive, ultra-efficient business.

That means that in one of the least-monolithic arenas of our culture — compare the needs of students in Hamilton County and Marion County, for example — small, medium and large are supposed to fit all.

Can't meet the benchmarks du jour? Then you and your student body don't deserve to stay in the game.

Like stockbrokers or attorneys bent on making partner, wise teachers are supposed to accept that their pay and promotions should be tied to "results." Those results depend on test scores, which seem to change with each legislature and which capture a one-dimensional, grainy snapshot of a growing, evolving child at a moment in time that may or may not resemble the same moment for all the other children in all the classes in all the schools.

"Healthy" competition is the name of the winning game, just as it is in a successful, for-profit company.  

The problem is, the bottom line of publicly educating children has never looked like a dynamite or dismal third quarter, a boatload of legal clients, a leveraged buyout or a disappointing IPO.

Few people remember now, but the idea of shifting school funding from local entities to the state was portrayed as a great relief for the locals. No more fretting over fluctuating property tax revenue and allocations for schools. But ask most local school superintendents how that's worked out, as their districts have become the money-sucking enemy in Indianapolis, their budgets have been cut, and more and more of them must beg their local citizens to vote for regular tax increases that will help keep the lights on and the math textbooks current.

Ask the superintendents again when the full effects of Indiana's constitutionally mandated tax caps are felt in a few years.

To hear the governor and his chief of public education talk, you would think Indiana is in the sub-basement of every national standard that exists. Such a sales approach makes radical restructuring (or demolition) so much easier. After all, who wants to keep a "failing" system in place? What person in his or her right mind wants to support an oil spill?

Never mind the individual faces, histories and value systems of more than 50,000 members of the state's teachers unions. Better to vilify them as a whole, hinting that those who do not buy the current administration's version of reform must be lazy, burned out, power-hungry or clinging to old-fashioned, inefficient methods.

Couple the vilification with statements from Bennett, such as, "We do not need any more money in this system. We need courage to change." Allow him to reduce the complex problems experienced by most public education systems throughout this country to a fake choice in Indiana between "funding school corporations" and funding "the education of students."

Repeat all of it, over and over again, and you can sell a lot of unproved reform to legislators and their constituents. You can demonize a lot of dedicated people, too, and belittle their life's work.

I doubt it will do much good because Americans prefer one-line "truths" to complicated explanations these days, but next Sunday, I'd like to provide some of the context the governor and superintendent never seem to include in their presentations. I'd like to try to balance their litany of failures with the very real successes of Indiana's public schools, and maybe offer some mitigating background information that requires more learning time than a pithy sound bite or a slick PowerPoint display.

Not a teacher or administrator I know thinks this state's public education system doesn't have problems or that all the remedies require more money. What they do think is that they are not an oil spill and that likening them to one is an insult they don't deserve.  

Thanks, Stephanie!

Friday, December 3, 2010

PBS Student Reporting Labs

Student Reporting LabsAn eSchool News article this week, PBS NewsHour launches student reporting website, tells of PBS NewsHour's Student Reporting Labs site that "connects students with professional mentors at their local public broadcasting station to produce original news reports on important national issues." Beta tested with just six schools last year, PBS is opening up the program to other schools this year, offering "technical instruction on the use of cameras and editing equipment...meaningful focus on understanding the role of journalism in society and developing broader communication skills, including listening, asking questions, public speaking, and finding, analyzing and evaluating the quality of information."  

Odds 'n' Ends

I like Laura Shumaker's simple Autism: 8 tips to help you survive the holidays and Linda Thomas's Faces in the Crowd: She overcame learning disability to help others like her. Thomas tells about the career of Carol Rosengarten, who knew "the frustration of a learning disability firsthand" and became an outstanding special educator.

Nick Anderson's House votes to send child nutrition bill to President Obama tells of the good and bad of the necessary bill. He has another article today that tells that Michelle Rhee has "joined the education transition team of Florida Gov.-elect Rick Scott."

Have a great weekend!

Enjoy the content on Educators' News and mathdittos2.com?

If so, why not come back and click through one of the links from our affiliate advertisers the next time you plan to purchase something online. We'll get a small commission from the sale, and you won't pay any more than you would have by directly going to the vendor's site.

Ads shown on this site do not represent an endorsement or warranty of any kind of products or companies shown. Ads shown on archive pages may not represent the ads displayed in the original posting on Educators' News.

Encounter Devotionals

by Zach Wood

 

 

Booksamillion.com: we wrote the book on low prices

 

 

Sam’s Club

 


Previous Week

About EdNews
News
Archive
mathdittos2.com
Features

©2010 Steven L. Wood