View from the Classroom
I'm Still Glad I Bought
When shopping for a computer, there's always that nagging little fear that says, "Wait a little longer." It seems that if you buy today, the price will go down 10% tomorrow, or a new model that is 100 MHz faster will be announced for the same money. Of course, with that kind of thinking, one might end up forever waiting for the perfect computer at the perfect price.
I bought my first G3 in March, 1998. It was (and is) a beige G3/266 MHz minitower that serves as my primary home computer. I purchased my second "G3," a Power Mac 7500 in December, 1998, and upgraded it with a Newer MAXpowr G3/250 MHz card for use at school. Both have performed admirably with almost nary a hiccup along the way. Both are obviously upgradable to more powerful chips. Both have an OrangeMicro PC card to provide full-speed Windows computing. And both are equipped with zip and floppy disk drives.
Before I switched over to the beige G3, I did most of my home computing on a Performa 575 that I upgraded with a DayStar PowerCard 601 to a PowerMac 575. While I still occasionally use that machine for testing software, it remains in regular use by our youngest, who now refers to it as "my computer."
The purchase price of the beige G3 was considerably more than a comparable Blue & White or even a G4. I'll be sending Apple Educator Loan Advantage a monthly check for some time to come for the beige G3. For the same money, a newer model would be fully paid by now!
There continues to be a strong upgrade market among Macintosh enthusiasts. Some folks upgrade existing machines, while others invest in used Macs to upgrade. For my school Mac, I obviously chose the latter route and upgraded it with new and existing parts. Had Apple still offered their education-only G3 All-in-one (Artemis), the nod would probably have gone to that way. Many other folks for reasons other than pure dollars have made similar choices. Charles W. Moore detailed how a professional photographer eschews the new Macs. The wedding photographer makes a convincing case for staying with the Power Mac 9500 with its onboard SCSI, 12 RAM slots, and 6 PCI slots for high end work.
When the beige G3 series was introduced, there was (and still is) considerable clammer about the lack of a true high-end Mac with adequate RAM and PCI slots. For me, that wasn't really a consideration. The pricing for the "best" Macs plummeted from around $4,000-5,000 to around $2500. Having long before received the required "marital approval" for a new Mac, I never looked back and took the plunge for my G3. Although the new pricing of the Blue & White G3's about broke my heart, around $1600, I'd already had 10 months use from my beige model by the time of that price break.
Along the way the beige G3 has received a few upgrades. With the advent of some excellent prices on PC 100 RAM used by some of the newer Macs, I popped for a 128 MB chip to push my RAM to 224 MB. The 100 MHz SDRAM works well in my beige G3, but I'm also at the point where with each upgrade, I'm removing a chip with nowhere to go with it because of the 3 RAM chip slot limitation on G3 Macintoshes.
When the stock 6 gig hard drive was getting crowded and beginning to make some new noises, I chose a Seagate Barracuda ATA/66 28 gig drive to replace it. Since my G3 has a revision 1 motherboard that does not support slaved drives, I couldn't use the old drive along with the new one.
I haven't as yet popped for a chip upgrade for several reasons. I once read something by a guy named Dan Knight that said you really ought to be able to double your chip speed to get your moneys worth out of such an upgrade. Since 266 MHz times 2 currently equals nothing on the market, I've sat tight waiting for something that comes stock (not overclocked) at better than 532 MHz. As I wait, I also keep seeing delicious rumors such as this one that appeared on MacOS Rumors March 21, 2000:
Numerous readers have sent emails detailing fantastic deals on 450 MHz upgrades. While I may yet settle for something less than my target speed, my second reason for not upgrading is that I'm waiting until faster upgrades become widely available and further drive down the prices on 450-500 MHz upgrades.
A third reason for not upgrading as yet is that I can't out type 266 MHz. For that matter, I really have to work at it to out type the chip speed on a Mac SE! I'm not a big gamer, nor do I run any monster number crunching applications, so the 266 MHz satisfies my needs, even when doing light photo editing. Of course, with that kind of reasoning, I should be content with 266 MHz forever. Don't believe it for a minute.
What have I missed with staying with Beige?
This column, like many, has sat on my hard drive for some time (creation date 9/8/99). While the new Power Macs have added an array of improvements not present in the beige G3 series, until this week only the 100 MHz system bus even remotely tempted me. Firewire and USB have also added to the Mac's versatility, but really weren't things I needed or wanted.
That changed a bit this week with Apple's release of iMovie as freeware! I don't even own a video cam, but I've already downloaded iMovie and plan to at least borrow a video camera. Now, there's just that Firewire requirement.
What has been lost with the new Macs?
Call me archaic, but I want my floppy drive...and I want it integrated in the Mac. I still find an internal floppy the easiest way to move a zip driver, one control panel, or one or two files from this Mac to that one. Yes, I have the school's Mac server sitting in my classroom. And yes, all of my classroom Macs are networked with Ethernet. When I move our weekly SpellTutor files, usually about a 6-10 MB transfer, I always use the network (if it's up, and it usually is). But for transferring just one small shareware or application, nothing beats a floppy and sneakernet. Just today, the whole network was DOWN. Usually in such cases when the Evil NT techie's server goes down, our Mac server continues merrily serving files and apps and directing print jobs. Today, it was all down, and I had to move a SpellTutor file from my Mac to all of the others in my classroom. Hooray for the floppy! It saved the day.
The techie is still denying all:-).
Onboard SCSI is no longer a stock part of shipping Macintoshes. As the SCSI standard evolves, folks who require SCSI are probably going to use a PCI SCSI adapter anyway, if they have enough slots available. Probably the biggest problem with Apple moving away from SCSI is just in dealing with two interfaces for hard drives. The hard drive you pull from an 8600 won't go into your iMac (Why would you want it too, anyway?).
Just for the fun of it, I pulled the product description of my now aging beige G3 and a comparable Apple offering of today.
Apple muddled for years with some so-so hardware and software at the expense of the faithful. Then folks began to leave in droves. The death spiral was narrowly escaped with System 8 followed by the G3's and the iMac. Now, as more speed and features are added to the Mac, it might be easy to sit and wait for something bigger and better before jumping into a new Mac. Certainly, watching for possible new model introductions is always prudent. However, from my experience with my now "outdated" G3, I can say it was probably best for me to buy beige despite the downward trend in prices of newer Macs. I may need to upgrade further, or even step up to a G4, or better yet, a G4e, but the increased productivity over the time I've had the unit outweighs any added features or cost differentials. And besides, my beige has a floppy!
Send your feedback to Steve Wood
©2000 Steven L. Wood